next up previous
Next: Ionization Time and nature Up: ROSAT PSPC Observation of Previous: Emission measuredensity and

Discussion

The most important results of the STNEI (this work) and CIE (Paper I) spatially resolved spectral analysis are: 1) the one temperature models fail to fit the data as a whole; 2) in those cases where the 1T STNEI model is appropriate the resulting ionization time is unexpectedly low; and 3) a 2T CIE model is usually adequate.

The first and third point were already reported in Paper I, where we analyzed the same data set using CIE models. Indeed, Itoh (1979) suggested that the X-ray spectrum of a hot plasma in NEI condition could be approximated by a two temperature CIE plasma model. Therefore, on the basis of the results reported in Paper I, a single component nature of the X-ray emission could not be definitely excluded. As we have seen in the previous section, when considering the new results of the STNEI spectral analysis, we find that the 1T STNEI model fails in the same location where the 2T CIE model was appropriate (for instance, consider the d3 bin and zone C in Paper I, or b6 and zone H in Paper I). However, this does not necessarily imply that the Itoh suggestion is wrong in our case: the NEI model used by Itoh for synthesizing the X-ray SNR emission was different from our STNEI model, because it was a sum of Sedov shells with different tex2html_wrap_inline802 values. Nevertheless, we interpret our results as a growing evidence that the medium in not homogeneous. If the medium was really homogeneous and the Sedov solution applied, then the peak in the NEI plasma emissivity (Fig. 1) and the peak in the Sedov density profile would yield a spectrum very similar to a STNEI spectrum, given the moderate PSPC spectral resolution.

We stress here that, in spite of the high counting statistics of our spectra, these results are not affected by uncertainties in the detector response, since they have been studied (Appendix A of Paper I) and accounted for by inclusion of systematic errors in the analysis.




next up previous
Next: Ionization Time and nature Up: ROSAT PSPC Observation of Previous: Emission measuredensity and

Fabrizio Bocchino
Wed Jan 15 13:20:09 MET 1997